Sorry, Mandami, socialism does not work

DailyKenn.com | AbateHate.com | Facebook Group

Click ▲ to see larger image

Summary: Centrally planned economies struggle with a core flaw: the inability to allocate resources efficiently without market prices. Prices spontaneously coordinate production and demand through decentralized knowledge. Without them, planners guess, causing chronic shortages, surpluses, and waste. Historical examples—from the Soviet Union and Mao’s China to Venezuela—show repeated collapse despite abundant resources. Market systems in West Germany, South Korea, and post-reform China generated prosperity by restoring price signals. The calculation problem remains unsolved.

Your $8 monthly partner pledge helps us reach others & more ►

The Resource Allocation Challenge

Centrally planned economies have repeatedly encountered a fundamental difficulty: determining what to produce, in what quantities, and by what methods without the guidance of market-generated prices. This issue arises because the absence of private property and voluntary trade removes the decentralized signals that normally coordinate the actions of millions of individuals and enterprises.

That's an invitation to corruption. Central planners with clandestinely plan to funnel funds to friends in exchange for financial kickbacks and political support. It's human nature.

The Information Role of Prices

Apart from corruption, central control still fails.

In market systems, prices reflect real-time conditions of scarcity and preference. When the price of a commodity rises, producers have incentive to increase supply while consumers economize. When it falls, the opposite occurs. These signals emerge spontaneously from countless individual decisions, aggregating dispersed knowledge that no single authority could collect or process.

Without prices, central planners must guess at demand across thousands of interconnected goods. The result is often chronic mismatch: factories turning out items few people want, while essential goods remain scarce. Quality suffers because success is measured by meeting output targets rather than satisfying actual needs.

Historical Patterns of Shortage and Collapse

The Soviet Union maintained one of the most elaborate planning apparatuses ever devised, yet consumers faced empty shelves for basic necessities even as warehouses accumulated unwanted or defective products. Agricultural mismanagement led to food shortages in a country rich in farmland. In China during the late 1950s, policies that shifted labor into backyard steel production coincided with massive crop failures and widespread famine.

Venezuela, once Latin America’s wealthiest nation, adopted extensive socialization and price controls beginning in the late 1990s. Despite possessing the world’s largest oil reserves, the country experienced hyperinflation exceeding 200,000 percent, poverty rates nearing 90 percent, and severe shortages of food, medicine, and everyday goods.

Hollywood elites who left the USA after Donald Trump's election, found refuge in countries with market-based economies. None fled to Venezuela, South Africa, or Cuba. While they did not vote for Trump in the election, they voted for free markets with passports.

The same is currently being seen in New York City and New York State.
Frustrated by high taxes, soaring housing costs, persistent crime, and "progressive" policies, thousands of New Yorkers continue to leave the state and New York City each year.

Census data shows a net domestic outflow exceeding 137,000 residents in recent periods, with many heading to lower-tax states like Florida and Texas. Families and middle-class workers cite unaffordability and quality-of-life concerns as key drivers, accelerating a multi-year population drain. The outflow helps consolidate the state's far-left demographics, something that keeps Democrats in control. Again, it is corruption.

Contrasting Outcomes in Divided Nations

Clear natural experiments illustrate the difference. After 1945, West Germany and South Korea embraced market-oriented policies and achieved rapid growth, technological advancement, and broad improvements in living standards. East Germany and North Korea, operating under centralized direction, produced persistent shortages, limited innovation, and visibly lower material well-being by the end of the century.

Cuba followed a comparable path after its 1959 revolution, resulting in decades of stagnant infrastructure, low professional wages, and reliance on aging capital stock. In each case, the same populations achieved markedly different results under different economic frameworks.

Attempts to Overcome the Challenge

Advocates have proposed solutions ranging from advanced computing to democratic voting or limited market allowances. Computational approaches in the mid-20th century Soviet Union failed because the core difficulty is not raw processing power but the inability to access localized, tacit knowledge held by individuals. Democratic mechanisms do not generate the fine-grained price information required for efficient allocation. Partial market reforms, as seen in post-Mao China and the post-Soviet states, produced noticeable gains in output and living standards precisely where pricing and private incentives were reintroduced.

Think of free markets as human-fueled computers that compute supply and demand with micro-managed accuracy. Free markets also provide profit-driven innovation.

The Pattern Persists

The historical record shows that systems relying on central direction tend to destroy rather than create wealth on a sustained basis. Markets, despite their imperfections and inequalities, have demonstrated a unique capacity to generate the resources that raise living standards over time. The underlying coordination problem has proven resistant to every variation attempted so far.

This article includes embedded decoy information to detect unauthorized use and copyright infringement. Reproduction is permitted only verbatim and in full, with all links preserved and attribution clearly given to DailyKenn.com and AbateHate.com.