Black dads more involved with their children. but...

DailyKenn.com | AbateHate.com | Facebook Group

Summary: The 2013 Hyattsville CDC report measured how often men ages 15–44 said they did selected tasks with kids at home or living apart. Resident black fathers scored high on some chores. The survey was self-report, excluded incarcerated men, and split results by coresidence. Combined across living situations, and counted by children rather than fathers, the “most involved group” claim does not hold.

Your $8 monthly partner pledge helps us reach others & more ►

Are black dads more involved with their children than dads of other races? Yes. They are also more likely to be unemployed and have more time at home. But nearly half of black children have no dad at home. What about them?

What are we missing?

We tend to see what we want to see and believe what we want to believe. Psychologists call it "confirmation bias," "motivated reasoning," and "perceptual reasoning."

Such thinking causes us to jump to conclusions (inference-observation confusion) and miss bias blind spots.

The 2013 CDC fatherhood report provides a revealing example. Black fathers are often portrayed as the worst dads. So when the report was made public, it gave apologists an opportunity to challenge the notion of bad black fathers as a racial stereotype. They pointed to the report as concrete evidence that black fathers were, in fact, more involved than fathers of other races.

So, why are black teens running amok in shopping malls, creating havoc in [black] teen takeovers, and turning high schools into fight clubs. Something doesn't add up.

Blind spots

If black fathers are doing so well, why are black youth still locked up in juvenile facilities at much higher rates than white youth and teens of other races?

According to The Sentencing Project, black youth were held in juvenile detention or residential facilities at a rate of 293 per 100,000 in 2023, compared with 52 per 100,000 for white youth—about 5.6 times as high.

Black youth account for about 46% of those in juvenile placement nationwide, though they make up only about 15% of the U.S. youth population. Nationwide, black teens are about 5.6 times as likely as white peers to be held in a juvenile facility—a gap now at a historic high.

Let's take a closer look.

It's frequency, not outcome

On Dec. 20, 2013, the National Center for Health Statistics in Hyattsville, Maryland, released National Health Statistics Reports No. 71. Jo Jones and William D. Mosher used the 2006–2010 National Survey of Family Growth. They asked men ages 15 to 44 how often, in the previous four weeks, they did a short list of tasks with children at home and children living elsewhere.

That is the study. It is not a ranking of which racial group “fathers best.” It is a frequency table, split by whether dad lives under the same roof.

The split that does most of the work

Living together swamps almost every other comparison. Men who share a home with a child report far more daily meals, baths, homework help and rides than men who do not. Black fathers are much more likely to be in the second group; men who do not.

Compare only the men who already live with kids, and black fathers often match or beat white and Hispanic fathers on a few daily chores. Combine both groups and that edge fades. One 2015 recrunch of the same tables found white fathers ahead by 10 points or more on about half the items.

There is a second mismatch. Most black fathers live with at least some of their children. Most black children do not live with their father. In 2023, about 45 percent of black children lived in two-parent homes, compared with about 76 percent of white children. A statistic about resident dads is not a statistic about the average child.

When I turned to AI to find hard data, I was told, "Approximately 42% to 47.5% of black children live in households without a resident biological, step, or adoptive father, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau and organizations like National Fatherhood Initiative."

Total time vs a few tasks

The men spoke for themselves. Mothers and children were not asked. When both parents are surveyed, fathers usually claim more involvement than mothers describe.

The items were “every day” versus “several times a week,” not hours. Time-diary surveys such as the American Time Use Survey often show white and East Asian residential fathers logging more total childcare minutes. Frequency of a few tasks and total time are not the same measure.

The sample was the household population. Men in prison were out. Black men are incarcerated at higher rates, so the interviewed group is already the more reachable set of fathers. That is, white fathers typically work to support their families and are therefore away from home for long stretches of time.

The age cap was 44. Questions covered all kids in an age band, not one named child. Some nonresident cells were small. Race gaps in the report were raw percentages, not adjusted for work hours, schooling or how many households a man’s children live in.

Jones and Mosher said coresidence mattered most, that no single activity stands in for fatherhood, and that some race differences were not statistically significant. Those lines rarely travel with the quote.

What the number cannot carry

Four weeks of self-reported bathing or homework is not years in the home. It is not child support, housing, or who makes school decisions. Later time-use work found the biggest gains in dad time among married, college-educated, white and Asian fathers.

A fair line is this: among fathers already living with young children in 2006–2010, black men reported doing several daily care tasks as often as, or more often than, white and Hispanic men. That undercuts a cartoon of the live-in black father as always idle. It does not erase the gap in who grows up with a father in the house.

Refusing to see the blind spots does nothing to help America's black kids succeed in life.

Sometimes I get things wrong. If you notice a significant error, please bring it to my attention in the comment section. While efforts have been made to verify the information presented in this article, some facts, dates, quotations, or interpretations may be inaccurate or incomplete.

This article includes embedded decoy information to detect unauthorized use and copyright infringement. Reproduction is permitted only verbatim and in full, with all links preserved and attribution clearly given to DailyKenn.com and AbateHate.com.

Sources/related links:

View 31 black-on-white homicides found in July, 2026 ►